The recruitment of chief executives in Kenya's public institutions requires a fundamental rethink. A hybrid selection system combining institutional representatives, independent professionals and sector-specific experts could offer the best safeguard against political interference, favouritism, subjective interviews and the appointment of unsuitable leaders.
Kenya needs to rethink how it recruits the people entrusted with running its most important public institutions. From the Teachers Service Commission (TSC) to State corporations, the quality of the leadership appointed determines whether public institutions deliver on their mandates or become centres of administrative inefficiency, financial mismanagement and unfulfilled promises.
The recruitment of a chief executive is not an ordinary human resource exercise. It is a national governance responsibility that demands exceptional professionalism, integrity, institutional understanding and the ability to deliver measurable results.
One fundamental question deserves attention: can a recruitment system that relies predominantly on an institution's own commissioners or board members guarantee that the most competent candidate will always emerge? Equally, should the responsibility of identifying the next chief executive be handed entirely to external recruitment agencies that may lack sufficient understanding of the institution's internal challenges and operational realities? Neither approach, standing alone, offers a perfect solution.
Kenya should seriously consider a hybrid system of executive recruitment that brings together institutional representatives, independent recruitment professionals and sector-specific experts. Such an arrangement would combine institutional knowledge with independent scrutiny, technical expertise and accountability.
The argument is not that existing procedures are entirely defective. Rather, the country should strengthen them by introducing safeguards that make it difficult for personal interests, political influence or institutional preferences to override professional merit.(Education News Kenya — https://educationnews.co.ke/news/tsc-needs-a-hybrid-system-in-ceo-recruitment-why-no-single-interview-panel-should-have-the-final-say)
The recruitment of the TSC Secretary and of the CEOs of State corporations operates under different constitutional and statutory arrangements. For the TSC, Article 250(12) of the Constitution of Kenya, 2010, provides for the appointment of a Secretary who serves as the Commission's chief executive officer. Section 16 of the Teachers Service Commission Act, 2012, specifically requires the appointment to be made through a competitive recruitment process. The law also prescribes minimum qualifications, including Kenyan citizenship, a degree in education from a recognised university, at least ten years' experience in the specified professional fields and compliance with Chapter Six of the Constitution. The TSC is therefore constitutionally empowered to recruit and appoint its Secretary. Its independence must be protected, and no external body should take over that responsibility.
For State corporations, recruitment is governed by the State Corporations Act, Cap. 446, the respective enabling legislation and applicable government guidelines. The National Treasury's 2024 Guidelines on Management and Terms and Conditions of Service for Board Members and Staff of State Corporations provide for competitive recruitment overseen by the respective boards. The process involves advertising vacancies, shortlisting candidates through the relevant human resource structures or recruitment agencies, and conducting final interviews through the board. The guidelines provide for identifying three top-performing candidates who meet the prescribed assessment threshold, followed by the applicable recommendation and approval process.
Although the two arrangements differ, they share a common responsibility: identifying people capable of managing public institutions professionally and delivering results. The challenge is how to make the selection process more credible without undermining the legal authority of the appointing institutions.
Why a hybrid selection system is necessary
One of the biggest weaknesses that can affect executive recruitment is the concentration of assessment responsibilities within a single group of people. Where an institution's own commissioners or board members dominate the entire exercise, there is a risk that internal preferences, institutional loyalties or external pressure may influence the assessment. Relying entirely on an external recruitment agency creates another problem: an agency may be experienced in executive recruitment but lack an intimate understanding of the institution's mandate, technical demands and historical challenges.
A hybrid selection panel would address both concerns. It would combine three groups: institutional representatives who understand the organisation, independent professionals who safeguard the credibility of the exercise, and sector-specific experts who can assess the technical competence of candidates. No single category would dominate the process, and it would be harder for an individual or a small group to manipulate the outcome, because candidates would face different but complementary forms of professional scrutiny.
The central argument is that public institutions should not choose their chief executives through an interview process that depends excessively on the preferences or judgement of a limited number of insiders.
How the hybrid panel should be constituted
Kenya could consider a nine-member selection panel for strategic public executive positions. Three members would represent the institution: in the case of TSC, commissioners nominated by the Commission, and for State corporations, board representatives. Two members would be independent professionals with expertise in human resource management, executive recruitment and organisational leadership. Two others would be sector-specific experts, who for TSC could be experienced professionals in education management, education policy, public administration or teacher management.
One member would be a governance and legal expert familiar with constitutional requirements, public sector accountability and statutory recruitment procedures. The ninth would be a public finance and accountability specialist able to assess financial management, institutional sustainability and responsible use of public resources. The panel could be chaired by an independent member selected through a transparent process, subject to the appointing institution's legal framework.
This composition would balance institutional knowledge, professional independence and technical competence. The hybrid panel should not, however, become another political appointment platform. Its members must be selected through clear professional criteria, declare conflicts of interest and undergo appropriate integrity checks.
For TSC, the Commission would retain its constitutional authority to appoint the Secretary, and the panel would serve as a structured assessment mechanism operating under that authority. For State corporations, the arrangement would have to respect the statutory responsibilities of the boards and be incorporated into the applicable recruitment guidelines and legislation where necessary.
The TSC Secretary requires more than an impressive interview
The need for a hybrid system is particularly evident in the responsibilities of the TSC Secretary. The office is not simply administrative. It coordinates the operations of an institution that manages one of the largest professional workforces in Kenya. The successful candidate must understand teacher management, education policy, public finance, human resource administration, labour relations and the changing demands of the education sector.
A candidate may have impressive academic qualifications and decades of administrative experience yet still struggle to address the practical challenges facing teachers and schools. This is why the selection panel must include professionals who understand the education sector beyond theory.
Candidates should be required to show how they would address persistent teacher shortages, particularly in Junior School, delayed promotions, teachers serving in acting capacities, career progression challenges, professional development and industrial relations. They should also explain how they would strengthen teacher deployment, improve human resource management and support the effective implementation of Competency-Based Education (CBE).
The interview should go beyond asking candidates what they know about TSC. It should establish what they intend to change, how they would implement those changes and what measurable results they expect to achieve. A candidate who cannot provide practical solutions to the challenges facing the institution should not succeed merely because of an impressive interview presentation.
Candidates should defend transformation agendas
Another important reform would be to require all shortlisted candidates to present institutional transformation plans before the panel. For the TSC Secretary, the presentation should address the immediate and long-term challenges affecting teachers and the education system. Candidates should explain how they intend to improve teacher recruitment and distribution, strengthen promotion processes, address staffing gaps, improve teacher welfare and enhance accountability. They should also show how they would manage the Commission's financial resources while keeping effective working relationships with teachers' unions, the Ministry of Education, school administrators and other stakeholders.
For other State corporations, candidates should present strategies on institutional efficiency, financial sustainability, revenue generation, service delivery and organisational reform. Such presentations would help distinguish candidates who understand the institutions they seek to lead from those simply pursuing prestigious public offices.
Published scoring criteria would reduce subjectivity
A hybrid selection panel must operate under a transparent and standardised scoring framework. Kenya should consider publishing assessment criteria before interviews begin so that every candidate understands how their performance will be evaluated.
A proposed 100-point framework could allocate 10 marks to academic and professional qualifications, 15 to relevant professional experience, 20 to leadership and management record, 20 to technical and sector knowledge, 15 to strategic vision and innovation, 10 to financial and governance competence and 10 to integrity and accountability. Panel members should independently score candidates before consolidating the results, and the weighting should be adjusted to reflect each institution's mandate and the requirements of the advertised position.
Candidates should face the same core questions and assessment standards, which would reduce the possibility of tailoring interviews to favour particular individuals. Academic qualifications should also not overshadow practical leadership. A candidate with several degrees but limited evidence of institutional transformation should not automatically outrank someone with a stronger record of delivering results.
The credibility of recruitment should not depend only on the assurance that an exercise was competitive. Kenyans should be able to understand how the successful candidate emerged. Institutions should publish selection criteria, disclose shortlisted candidates subject to applicable privacy requirements, document the reasons for their decisions and provide mechanisms for challenging procedural irregularities. Final assessment results should be disclosed to the extent permitted by law, with confidential personal information protected. Every panel member should declare potential conflicts of interest and withdraw where necessary, and the process should keep proper records to allow independent scrutiny if allegations of favouritism or irregularities arise.
Political interference must not determine who gets the job
Political interference remains one of the most sensitive issues in senior public appointments. Article 232 of the Constitution establishes the values and principles of public service, including fair competition and merit as the basis of appointments and promotions. The hybrid system would help protect those principles by ensuring that recruitment decisions face professional scrutiny from different perspectives.
For State corporations, boards must exercise their statutory responsibilities without undue external influence. For TSC, the Commission must retain its constitutional independence in recruiting its Secretary. Government oversight should promote accountability and should not become an opportunity to replace professional judgement with political preference. The purpose of introducing independent experts is to strengthen the credibility of the exercise and make it harder for predetermined outcomes to prevail.
Even the most transparent recruitment exercise cannot guarantee that a successful candidate will become an effective chief executive, which is why recruitment must be linked to measurable performance. The TSC Secretary should work under clearly defined targets covering teacher recruitment, promotions, distribution, professional development, teacher welfare, financial accountability and institutional efficiency. State corporation CEOs should likewise be evaluated against their institutions' financial and operational objectives.
Annual independent performance assessments should determine whether executives are meeting their contractual obligations, and contract renewal should depend on demonstrable results and not on political connections, personal relationships or institutional loyalty. Kenya could also consider strengthening oversight of executive recruitment through a legally established professional framework that monitors compliance with recruitment standards without taking over the constitutional powers of independent commissions or the statutory responsibilities of State corporation boards.
The proposed model should not be misunderstood as a call to establish another government body or create more bureaucratic positions. Its purpose is to improve the quality of decision-making by combining the strengths of existing institutional structures with independent professional expertise. Institutional representatives understand the organisation. Independent recruitment professionals understand how to identify leadership talent. Sector specialists understand the technical demands of the job. Governance and finance experts help safeguard legality and accountability. Bringing these competencies together would produce a more balanced and credible selection process, and reduce the danger of placing excessive power in the hands of a single institution, recruitment agency or group of insiders.
The appointment of a TSC Secretary is not merely the recruitment of another senior public officer. It is a decision that affects teachers, learners, parents, school administrators and the future direction of education in Kenya. Likewise, the recruitment of State corporation CEOs should be treated as a national governance priority, because their decisions affect public investments, jobs, essential services and economic development.
Kenya must move beyond recruitment exercises that concentrate excessively on academic credentials, interview performance and administrative experience. The country needs a hybrid selection system that combines institutional authority, independent professional assessment, sector-specific expertise and transparent accountability.
The objective should be simple: recruit leaders because they are competent, not because they are connected, and appoint them because they can deliver, not because they can impress an interview panel. Kenya needs institutional builders, not just office holders. The future of public institutions should be determined by merit, integrity and the capacity to transform lives.
Reader Discussion (0)
Sign in to comment