It is a contradiction that exposes a troubling culture in which professional competence sometimes appears less important than personal loyalty, flattery and unquestioning obedience.
When TSC advertises administrative positions, evaluates applicants, conducts interviews and deploys successful candidates, it expects them to discharge specific responsibilities within the established school management structure. These are not honorary appointments or positions whose legitimacy depends on whether the institutional head likes the officeholder.
Yet, in some institutions, substantive deputies find themselves occupying offices whose authority exists largely on paper. Instead of working closely with the officially appointed deputy, the head develops a parallel administrative arrangement, relying heavily on another teacher who enjoys personal confidence or is considered more agreeable.
Some substantive deputies are excluded from important management discussions, denied meaningful responsibilities and overlooked when decisions affecting the institution are made. Meanwhile, teachers without substantive administrative appointments gradually assume influential roles because they enjoy the head’s confidence.
Competence before personal loyalty
One troubling explanation for this tendency is the preference some institutional heads appear to have for unquestioning loyalty over professional competence. They are more comfortable working with teachers who constantly praise them, defend their decisions and rarely challenge their actions, even when those decisions deserve scrutiny.
Such arrangements risk creating administrative cheerleaders whose priority is pleasing the institutional head rather than strengthening school management. Where loyalty discourages scrutiny, administrative shortcomings, questionable decisions or misconduct may go unchallenged.
This creates an unhealthy environment in which professional honesty is mistaken for disloyalty, constructive criticism is interpreted as rebellion and independent thinking becomes a source of conflict.
The substantive deputy who insists on proper procedures, accountability and transparency may consequently be labelled difficult, while the teacher who agrees with everything becomes the preferred confidant.
This is a dangerous reversal of institutional priorities. Schools need administrators who offer honest professional advice, identify weaknesses and recommend corrective measures. They need management structures that address mistakes rather than conceal them.
A substantive deputy should be a trusted professional partner, with responsibilities that reflect the appointment.
Under Article 237 of the Constitution, TSC’s functions include recruiting and employing registered teachers, assigning teachers to public schools, and promoting and transferring teachers. Administrative appointments and deployments must therefore follow the commission’s applicable procedures.
An institutional head provides overall school leadership, but that responsibility should not be treated as unrestricted authority to disregard established administrative appointments.
There is an important distinction between delegating particular responsibilities to another teacher and systematically undermining an officially appointed deputy. A head may assign duties according to institutional needs, professional expertise and operational demands. However, such discretion should not render substantive appointments meaningless.
The same concerns extend to senior teachers whose appointments sometimes appear to carry little practical significance when responsibilities are distributed. Although senior teachers do not automatically have a right to every delegated duty, their professional positions and contributions deserve recognition.
Teamwork is a leadership responsibility
The problem becomes particularly concerning when personal disagreements determine the distribution of administrative responsibilities.
A deputy who expresses independent opinions, questions decisions or insists on accountability should not automatically become an enemy of the institutional head. Differences in management style and professional opinion are inevitable. What matters is resolving them without compromising institutional performance.
A competent Head of Institution should be capable of working professionally with a deputy appointed by TSC.
Leadership requires building a functional team, managing different personalities, accommodating professional opinions and ensuring that institutional objectives take precedence over individual interests.
The measure of a head’s competence includes the ability to work professionally with the officer deployed by the commission, even where their personalities or approaches differ.
A head who requires a personally selected deputy to function effectively should reflect on their own leadership capacity. Emotional intelligence, conflict resolution, professional maturity and effective delegation are essential attributes of institutional leadership.
The substantive deputy, equally, must respect the established chain of command, cooperate with the institutional head and contribute to the school’s success. The relationship should be complementary rather than competitive.
Creating parallel centres of authority carries wider institutional risks. Teachers may begin identifying with different camps, communication can break down, professional confidence deteriorates and decision-making becomes increasingly personalised.
Where concealment replaces accountability, the damage can extend beyond staff relationships to financial management, learner welfare, examination integrity and institutional credibility.
A school cannot build a culture of integrity when protecting individuals from scrutiny takes precedence over safeguarding professional standards.
TSC must make appointments meaningful
These concerns raise questions about the effectiveness of TSC’s supervision of school leadership. Recruitment, promotions, transfers and examination performance matter, but so do the professional relationships that determine whether institutions function effectively.
Formal appointments must not be confused with ordinary delegation of duties. The commission should ensure that institutional heads understand this distinction and that appointed officers can fulfil their responsibilities.
Where a substantive deputy believes their position is being deliberately undermined, the matter should not degenerate into personal confrontation. The officer should seek clarification, document specific instances of exclusion and, where necessary, approach the relevant Sub-County or County TSC Director for intervention.
TSC should also consider how effectively institutional heads work with appointed deputies when assessing leadership performance.
Examination results, discipline, financial accountability and curriculum implementation are important indicators of school performance. The ability of administrators to work as a professional team deserves attention alongside them.
There is little justification for investing resources in competitive recruitment and administrative appointments if successful officers can subsequently be reduced to spectators through personal preferences.
A public school’s administrative structure must serve its educational mandate. Access to responsibility should not depend primarily on a teacher’s personal relationship with the head.
Kenya’s education system needs administrators who place loyalty to the institution above loyalty to an individual. A teacher’s responsibility includes protecting the school’s integrity and raising legitimate concerns through appropriate channels.
Institutional heads must recognise the authority behind substantive appointments, while deputies must treat their positions as opportunities to serve rather than platforms for competing with their heads.
Ultimately, school leadership should be measured by transparency, teamwork, accountability, professional competence and the delivery of quality education.
TSC must ensure that its appointments carry practical institutional meaning. A substantive deputy should be recognised as a legitimate member of the school’s management team and given responsibilities consistent with that role.
The fundamental question remains: if an institutional head cannot work professionally with a deputy appointed through the commission’s established process, should their own leadership competence not come under scrutiny?













Reader Discussion (0)
Sign in to comment