When a school fires ten teachers at once, the problem may not be the teachers

When a school fires ten teachers at once, the problem may not be the teachers
Photo generated by AI for illustrative purposes
Listen to this story
0:00
5 min read
The decision by a top private school to terminate the contracts of ten teachers simultaneously should provoke more questions than answers. Employers have the right to reorganise their workforce in accordance with the law, but mass termination of teachers should not automatically be celebrated as decisive leadership or interpreted as evidence of professional incompetence. Sometimes, what appears to be a staffing problem is actually a management problem. What is presented as a performance crisis could, in reality, be a financial crisis, a governance failure, a leadership disagreement or the consequence of an institutional strategy that has gone terribly wrong.
Sacking teachers is often the easiest reaction to a complicated institutional problem. It takes considerably more courage and managerial competence to investigate the circumstances that created the problem in the first place. 
When ten teachers are shown the door at about the same time, the natural question is whether all ten independently failed to meet professional expectations. Did they all suddenly become incompetent? Did their teaching abilities deteriorate simultaneously? Or could there be an underlying institutional problem that management would rather not confront?

A school is much more than a collection of classrooms and teachers. It is an ecosystem comprising management, governance structures, parents, learners, financial systems, institutional culture and professional leadership. These components are interconnected, and when one fails, the consequences can easily spill into others. Unfortunately, teachers often become the most convenient casualties of institutional disagreements and administrative failures.

One possibility worth examining is the school's financial position. Private schools operate in an increasingly competitive education environment. Rising operational costs, declining enrolment, unpaid school fees and ambitious expansion programmes can create enormous financial pressure. An institution that has invested heavily in infrastructure, marketing or expansion without carefully evaluating its financial sustainability may eventually struggle to meet its obligations. Reducing the teaching workforce may offer temporary financial relief, but it does not address the decisions that created the difficulties. Dismissing ten teachers cannot magically correct poor financial planning.
Another possibility is a leadership or governance crisis. Private schools sometimes experience disagreements between proprietors, directors, boards, principals and professional administrators. Differences over institutional direction, financial priorities, management authority and operational decisions can create an uncomfortable working environment. In such circumstances, employees may find themselves caught in conflicts they neither initiated nor have the authority to resolve. When leadership disagreements become entrenched, dismissing staff can become a convenient way of asserting authority rather than addressing the substantive issues.
There is also the question of institutional culture. A school that frequently hires and dismisses teachers risks creating an environment of professional insecurity. Teachers who constantly fear losing their jobs may become reluctant to exercise professional judgement, challenge questionable administrative decisions or contribute honestly to institutional improvement. They may prioritise pleasing management over improving learning outcomes. Such an environment does not encourage innovation, professional growth or genuine commitment to learners.
Effective performance management also cannot be reduced to issuing termination letters. If teachers are underperforming, management should have credible evidence, established appraisal procedures and clearly communicated performance expectations. Professional development, mentorship, classroom supervision and constructive feedback should form part of the process. Dismissal should not become the default response whenever examination results disappoint or management encounters resistance. Accountability is important, but accountability without fairness easily degenerates into intimidation.
The consequences of mass teacher exits extend beyond the affected employees. Parents pay substantial school fees with the expectation that their children will receive quality, consistent and uninterrupted education. They deserve to know whether the institution has a sustainable staffing strategy. When ten teachers leave simultaneously, learners may experience disrupted lessons, weakened teacher-learner relationships and uncertainty about academic programmes. Replacing teachers may be relatively easy, but rebuilding professional relationships, institutional continuity and classroom stability takes time.
There is also a reputational dimension that school owners should not underestimate. Parents increasingly evaluate schools not only through examination results, impressive buildings and marketing campaigns but also through institutional stability, staff welfare and management credibility. 
A school that repeatedly experiences mass staff departures may eventually raise questions about its working environment. The departure of ten teachers does not automatically establish wrongdoing by management, but neither should the institution assume that parents will interpret such a development as proof of decisive leadership.

This is not an argument that teachers should enjoy immunity from professional accountability. Teaching is a serious responsibility, and incompetence, misconduct, negligence and persistent underperformance must have consequences. Schools must retain the freedom to restructure their operations where legitimate circumstances demand it. However, employment decisions should be supported by credible reasons, procedural fairness and compliance with applicable labour laws. The existence of an employment contract does not give either party unlimited freedom to disregard its legal obligations.

Perhaps the most important consideration is the need for institutional introspection. Before dismissing ten teachers, school leadership should ask whether its recruitment practices, supervision systems, financial decisions, communication structures and management philosophy are working. It should examine whether teachers received adequate support, whether expectations were realistic and whether management itself contributed to the difficulties being experienced.
Ultimately, the issue is not simply why ten teachers were dismissed. It is what happened within the institution to make their collective departure appear necessary. The public should resist the temptation to judge the affected teachers without understanding the circumstances surrounding their exit.
Perhaps the teachers were the problem. But perhaps they were only the most visible casualties of a much deeper institutional failure.
A school cannot permanently solve a management crisis by repeatedly changing the people standing in front of classrooms. Sometimes, the people who need performance appraisal are not the teachers but those occupying the offices from which the dismissal letters are issued.
Ashford Kimani is a teacher of English and Literature and writes on education and youth affairs








You can also follow our social media pages on Twitter: Education News KE and Facebook: Education News Newspaper for timely updates.


>>> Click here to stay up-to-date with trending regional stories


 >>> Click here to read more informed opinions on the country's education landscape


>>> Click here to stay ahead with the latest national news.

Reader Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment
Please keep comments respectful & constructive.
No approved comments yet. Be the first to share your opinion!

Continue reading

6 recommendations
Chat with us