- Schools have often defaulted to blaming teachers for declining performance without first examining whether leadership, communication and support systems are functioning properly.
- Effective school leadership has been shown to combine high expectations with genuine support, recognition and consistent accountability rather than blame or intimidation.
- Persistent poor results, high staff turnover and low morale have been identified as signals that leaders should first fix systemic weaknesses before replacing teachers.
When a school begins to struggle, one of the easiest things to do is blame the teachers. The complaints are familiar: teachers are no longer committed, they are not working hard enough, they are arriving late, failing to complete the syllabus or neglecting learners.
When examination results decline, teachers are often among the first placed under scrutiny. But before school leaders conclude that teachers are the reason their institutions are struggling, there is a more uncomfortable question they should ask themselves: have they created an environment in which good teachers can actually succeed?
This question matters because teacher performance does not exist in isolation. Even a highly trained, experienced and committed teacher can struggle inside a poorly managed school. A good teacher can enter the classroom every morning prepared to teach, yet the environment surrounding that teacher can either strengthen professional commitment or gradually weaken it. Imagine working in a school where communication is poor, expectations are unclear, instructions arrive at the last minute and policies change without adequate explanation. Teachers are expected to deliver excellent results, but they are rarely given the information, resources or support needed to achieve them, and when performance declines, the same teachers are blamed.
Teachers need clarity about what is expected of them, when it should be done and how their performance will be evaluated. Clear communication reduces confusion and allows teachers to concentrate on their most important responsibility: teaching and supporting learners. Leadership support is equally important. A teacher dealing with a difficult learner, an overcrowded classroom, inadequate teaching materials, excessive workload or a challenging academic programme may need professional support rather than immediate condemnation. When every challenge is met with blame, teachers can become frustrated, defensive and eventually disengaged.
ALSO READ:
Lobby group urges TSC to act on rising depression cases among North Rift, Western Kenya teachers
This does not mean teachers should escape accountability. Teachers have professional obligations to prepare lessons, attend classes, assess learners, complete assigned responsibilities, maintain appropriate discipline and uphold the standards expected of the profession. Accountability remains essential, but it should never be confused with intimidation. Effective leadership combines high expectations with appropriate support; a strong school leader does not lower standards because teachers face challenges, but instead asks what can be done to help teachers meet those standards.
Recognition is another important ingredient of a healthy school environment. Teachers who consistently perform well, mentor colleagues, support struggling learners, organise school programmes or contribute beyond their basic responsibilities need to know that their work matters. Recognition does not always require financial rewards; a sincere word of appreciation, constructive feedback, a certificate, an opportunity to lead or simple acknowledgement during a staff meeting can strengthen morale. Conversely, when exceptional effort is repeatedly ignored while mistakes receive immediate attention, teachers may begin to feel that nothing they do is good enough, which can quietly damage the culture of an entire school.
School leaders must also examine how they respond when things go wrong. In a weak leadership culture, every problem becomes a search for someone to blame: examination results fall, and teachers are blamed, discipline deteriorates, and teachers are blamed; parents complain, and teachers are blamed. Strong leadership takes a different approach, asking not only “Who is responsible?” but “Why did this happen, and what can we change to prevent it from happening again?” That shift from blame to problem-solving can transform a school, encouraging teachers to report challenges early instead of hiding them, allowing leaders to identify weaknesses in systems, and allowing staff to participate in finding solutions.
ALSO READ: KUPPET accuses MPs of interfering with TSC’s Independence over appointment letters row
School culture also matters. A school where teachers feel constantly threatened, humiliated or unfairly treated is unlikely to bring out their best professional performance, while a school where teachers are respected, listened to and held accountable within clear professional boundaries is more likely to develop a motivated and responsible workforce. Respect, however, should never mean tolerating indiscipline. Great leadership creates a balance between support and accountability, where teachers know what is expected of them, understand the consequences of failing to meet professional standards, and receive fair treatment when concerns arise.
If a school has persistent poor results, high staff turnover, low morale, frequent conflicts or repeated disciplinary challenges, replacing teachers should not automatically be the first solution. Should leadership first examine the system: are workloads reasonable, is communication effective, are teachers properly supported, are resources available, are policies applied consistently, are good performers recognised, and are staff concerns addressed before they become major disputes? These questions can reveal weaknesses that might otherwise be incorrectly attributed entirely to teachers.
MPs question Sh104 billion capitation disbursed on unverified NEMIS learner data
The strongest schools are not necessarily those with perfect teachers, since no school has perfect teachers. They are schools that deliberately create conditions in which teachers can perform at their best, establishing clarity, encouraging teamwork, recognising achievement, addressing weaknesses, providing support and maintaining professional accountability. Their leaders understand that their responsibility is not simply to supervise teachers, but to build an environment in which both teachers and learners can thrive.
Teachers must be willing to examine their own performance, but school leaders must be equally willing to examine theirs. Before saying “our teachers are the problem,” the harder question is what leaders have done to make it possible for good teachers to succeed. Sometimes the problem is not the people. Sometimes it is the system surrounding them, and sometimes, before replacing good teachers, schools need to fix the environment that is preventing those teachers from succeeding.
By Hillary Muhalya
Get more stories from our website: Education News
To write to us or offer feedback, you can reach us at: editor@educationnews.co.ke
You can also follow our social media pages on Twitter: Education News KE and Facebook: Education News Newspaper for timely updates.
>>> Click here to stay up-to-date with trending regional stories
